Thing in the Ice // Awoken Horror #92 from Shadows over Innistrad is a foil rare card that currently sells for about $1.10 ungraded, with graded copies ranging from $24.99 at grade 9 to $27.00 at grade 9.5. A grade 9.5 copy sells for around $27.00, about 25× the $1.10 raw price, so high-grade copies are worth grading.